You don’t have to spend very much time interacting with atheists on the internet before you hear this objection: “There are almost 5,000 gods being worshiped by humans, but don’t worry… only yours is right.” The picture above was sent to me on Twitter last week in response to my blog about God’s hiddenness. There are other very popular forms of this argument. Richard Dawkins claims that Christians are atheists when it comes to Zeus, Thor, the Flying Spaghetti Monster, and many others. Dawkins just goes one god further than the Christian. So the claim is either than I’m an atheist when it comes to 4,999 gods or that I’m dumb for claiming to have truth when I reject so many other options.
The reason this argument is so popular on the internet is that it is easy. It fits into 140 characters for Twitter and can easily be turned into a meme. Here are examples I found from a very quick search on Twitter.
“There have been nearly 3000 Gods so far but only yours actually exists. The others are silly made up nonsense. But not yours. Yours is real.”
“there are thousands of religions practices. thousands of gods worshiped. but don’t worry. yours is the only right one.”
“30,000 religions and 5000 versions of Christianity and only ‘yours’ is the right one-you are a joke.”
“Roughly 4200 religions in the world; and only yours is the right one? You must be a genius and everyone else is dumb to not pick yours.”
This objection also works well because a good response can’t fit on Twitter or a meme (like most good responses or argument), and so it seems like the Christian is left without an answer. If you try to answer on Twitter, you are most likely going to get another short objection. Instead of giving you a short Twitter response, I will hopefully help you understand this objection. This will help you see that there is a response and that the is just a bad, popular level objection. There’s nothing to worry about for the Christian.
Let’s start by applying the same logic of this objection to other scenarios to see if it even makes sense. The basic idea of this argument is that since different people believe different things, it is unreasonable to think that you are right. If a married couple does their finances and comes to two different conclusions on how much money is in their bank, does that mean they can’t know the truth? No, it means that either both are wrong or one is right and the other is wrong. Disagreement doesn’t lead to the absence of truth. A person can have the truth in a world of contrary beliefs.
The second idea I see with this objection is that Christians are basically atheists because they reject thousands of other gods. Does that follow? Is a married man basically a bachelor because he isn’t married to thousands of other women? To say that I am an atheist when it comes to Zeus and Thor is like saying a married man is a bachelor when it comes to women other than his wife. The difference between a bachelor and a married man is the difference between a theist and an atheist. You would never say a married man is a bachelor for every other woman. Therefore, it doesn’t make sense to say that a Christian is an atheist to every other God.
Imagine looking at a police lineup and telling the officer that person #4 committed the crime. What would you say if the officer responded by saying, “There are four other possible suspects… but only your guy is the right one-you’re a joke.” I don’t think you would say “Good point officer, I guess we are done here.” If this objection worked, defense attorneys could win every trial by saying “Roughly 7 billion people in the world; and only yours is the right one? You must be a genius and everyone else is dumb to not pick yours.” There’s a reason we don’t see this objection being used with police or in court.
The reason we don’t see these situations in court is that we base the innocence or guilt of a suspect on evidence. We know that not all suspects are the same, and in the same way, not all gods are the same. If there is positive evidence that a certain person committed a crime, then we have good reason to rule out all other possible suspects. We don’t use the possibility of other suspects to say that we can’t know who committed the crime. If that were true, no one would go to jail. If we can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that one person is guilty, then other possible suspects are innocent. In the same way, I am convinced that we can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the Christian God exists.
The reasonable person makes a conclusion based on the evidence, and this is why it is reasonable to conclude that I do have the truth in a world of different beliefs. There is very good evidence that God exists. I won’t get into that evidence here, but I barely scratched the surface of examining the evidence when I wrote my blog Is Belief in God a Rational Position? These are just three of over a dozen arguments for His existence. A big difference that atheists, who present this objection, fail to recognize is that Thor, Zeus, and the Flying Spaghetti Monster are all gods inside the universe. The Christian God exists outside the universe and is the creator of all physical things. We are talking about very different categories.
August 2, 2016 at 4:19 pm
If you are a Christian you do not have to believe that all the other religions are simply wrong all through. If you are an atheist you do have to believe that the main point in all the religions of the whole world is simply one huge mistake. If you are a Christian, you are free to think that all these religions, even the queerest ones, contain at least some hint of the truth….But, of course, being a Christian does mean thinking that where Christianity differs
from other religions, Christianity is right and they are wrong. As in arithmetic—there is only one right answer to a sum, and all other answers are wrong: but some of the wrong answers are much nearer being right than others.
Click to access merechristianitylewis.pdf
August 7, 2016 at 12:55 am
Thanks for the comment! I agree with you. Other religions can have pieces of truth, but if Christianity is true, then not other religion can be completely true.
August 2, 2016 at 4:23 pm
Good stuff. Love the logic. Students in puclic school need to know this kind of stuff.
August 7, 2016 at 12:54 am
August 2, 2016 at 9:01 pm
I believe there is only one God. There is a worship song that perplexes me every time we sing it. “Our God is greater…”. Our God? In comparison to other gods?
Like I mentioned… it’s perplexing. Perhaps it’s just me.
August 7, 2016 at 12:55 am
Interesting thought. That had never crossed my mind before.
November 9, 2019 at 10:51 pm
As a Christian we believe that there are angels and demons, as well as an enemy of God. When we sing our God is higher than any other, we are not referring to other gods, we are referring to these spiritual entity’s. Lyrics are very poetic. It can also mean God is higher than any other “thing” as well as person.
October 25, 2016 at 8:55 am
@Jordan M. Lewis what you're talking about smacks of interfaithism. Saying that Jesus is the same as Buddha or Allah or Krishna or Odin. The proof is in Acts 4:12 Neither is there salvation in any other: for there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved.
October 27, 2016 at 12:15 pm
Matthew, I did not say that Jesus is the same as those other false gods. I merely quoted C.S. Lewis in saying that we can look at any religion and see a few elements they have right, like that there is a deity and a reason for life rather other than chance and accident. By saying so, we do not in any way give up our right to say–emphatically and without ambivalence–that the false religion is false. We merely acknowledge that the religion has at least come to the correct conclusion on certain issues.
It’s like seeing three doors, two of which are blue and one that is green. You know that the blue door in the middle is the correct door and that the blue door on the left hand side leads to certain death. So it is true that “the correct path is found through a blue door;” but it is not correct that either blue door is the right way. Yet the one who perishes by the wrong blue door may have known a little more than the one who perishes through the green door, who was wholly ignorant that no green door could lead to the right way.
I hope this analogy helps. Anyone who follows any other path but Christ is not saved. But a person might learn things from a false religion like the existence of absolute truth, the existence of God, and the concept of sacrificial love, etc. Indeed, it is those same truths embedded in falsity that may be a greater stumbling block than pure falsity alone. We must acknowledge and understand these truths so that we can point out where they are corrupted.
February 12, 2017 at 5:24 pm
Reblogged this on Cyber Penance and commented:
By Ryan Pauly
September 9, 2022 at 5:48 pm
Thank you for sharing excellent informations. Your web site is very cool. I’m impressed by the details that you have on this web site. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found just the information I already searched everywhere and simply could not come across. What a perfect website.